Rutherford B. Hayes, 19th President of the United States

“Unjust attacks on public men do them more good than unmerited praise.” He was the first president of have actually graduated from law school (previous presidents had studied under other lawyers). His was the most disputed election in history. He banned wine and liquor from the White House, much to the displeasure of guests. He also hosted the first White House Easter Egg Roll. He is Rutherford Birchard Hayes, 19th President of the United States, serving from March 4, 1877, until March 4, 1881. Rutherford was born on October 4, 1822, in Delaware, Ohio, to a single mother, as his father died before he was born. Although his mother never remarried, Rutherford looked up to his uncle, who became a father figure in his life and contributed to his early education. Rutherford ultimately graduated from Harvard Law School in 1845, and began practicing in Sandusky, Ohio, before moving to Cincinnati in 1849, where he first became active in the Republican Party.

On December 30, 1852, Rutherford married Lucy Webb, who had graduated from Wesleyan Women’s College, making her the first future First Lady to have graduated from college. Lucy was a Methodist and supported the abolition of alcohol and slavery, views which influenced Rutherford’s behavior, although Rutherford never formally joined the Methodist church.


Rutherford first gained attention as an attorney for his defense of criminals, specifically several individuals accused of murder and for escaped, runaway slaves. His defense of slaves, and support of abolition, continued to gain him prominence within the Republican party. In 1856, Rutherford refused a nomination for a judgeship. In 1858, he eventually accepted the office of city solicitor from the city council when it became vacant. He went on to win a full, two-year term from the people in the 1859 election.


Following the election of Abraham Lincoln, several Southern states seceded, and Rutherford was lukewarm over the idea of using a civil war to restore the Union, however, Rutherford joined the Army after the war began. During his time in the military, Rutherford served with future president William McKinley. Rutherford rose the rank of major general and suffered sever injuries during the Battle of South Mountain. Although the Civil War did not end until 1865, in 1864, Rutherford was nominated to run for a seat in the House of Representatives. Despite refusing the leave the Army and campaign, Rutherford won the seat, beating out the incumbent.


Rutherford disagreed with many of the actions of then President Andrew Jackson. Rutherford supported the 14th Amendment, and wanted to ensure that the southern states were re-admitted to the Union with laws in place to protect the newly freed slaves. Rutherford did not agree with the president pardoning many leading members of the Confederacy. Rutherford worked to pass the Civil Rights Act of 1866, and the Tenure of Office Act. Rutherford won re-election in 1866, but resigned in July of 1867 to run for governor of Ohio, to which he was elected.


As Governor of Ohio, Rutherford had a limited role, as he had no veto power and an opposing legislature for his first term. In Rutherford’s second term, he enjoyed a Republican legislature, and had their support in ratifying the 15th Amendment of the United States Constitution, guaranteeing black suffrage. Rutherford also helped establish what would go on to become Ohio State University. Rutherford looked forward to retiring in 1872, following his second term.


Rutherford returned to the position of governor in 1875. His success as governor elevated him to the top of the Republican party, leading to a nomination for the Republican presidential candidate. Rutherford and William Wheeler (the vice-presidential candidate) ran against Samuel J. Tilden. Rutherford and Samuel shared many similarities, including a reputation for honesty and supporting civil reform. The election was close, with Tilden appearing to have won, but falling one vote short of the necessary majority of the electoral college. The votes from Florida, Louisiana, and South Carolina, along with some of Oregon’s votes, were all in dispute due to fraud by both parties. In January of 1877, with the votes still disputed, President Grant authorized an Electoral Commission to determine the outcome of the election, which eventually went to Rutherford.


Rutherford Hayes became the first President of the United States to be sworn in inside the White House on Sunday, March 4, 1877. He was publicly sworn in on the following Monday. Rutherford was secretly sworn in due to discontent over his election. As part of the agreement to his election, Rutherford ended the Reconstruction in the South, returning it to home rule. Rutherford continued to support equal rights acts, however, he was often blocked by an opposing House. One of the first issues Rutherford was forced to deal with was the Railroad Strike of 1877. Railroad workers went on strike following several wage cuts that year. Rutherford was forced to send in federal troops to end riots and force workers to return to work, while their pay cuts were still in place.


Rutherford was against the spoils system, or giving federal jobs to political supporters. Instead Rutherford believed, and acted upon the belief, that jobs should be given to those most qualified. These reforms were unpopular among both parties and Rutherford was unable to completely abolish the spoils system, although he did improve it. Chinese immigrants were blamed for the Railroad Strike, and before that, the Panic of 1873, leading to many wanting to restrict the flow of Chinese immigrants, which went against a previously signed treaty with the Chinese. Rutherford refused to support the 1879 act limiting Chinese immigrants, leading to many calling for his impeachment.


Also internationally, Rutherford mediated a territorial dispute between Argentina and Paraguay. Paraguay responded to his help by renaming a city after him, Villa Hayes. Rutherford also granted permission to the Army to pursue bandits into Mexico, an act which angered the Mexican president. Bandits would often cross the Mexican border in Texas, raid towns and ranches before crossing back into Mexico where the Army could not pursue them. Rutherford and the Mexican president reached an agreement in which both countries would work together to pursue the bandits. Additionally, Rutherford agreed to not allow Mexican revolutionaries to build armies in the States. This agreement decreased violence along the border.


Disappointed in the drunken behavior of guests at his first White House reception, Rutherford banned alcohol from the White House. He also wanted to set a good example for the nation. Rutherford’s wife earned the nickname “Lemonade Lucy,” as it is thought she was the instigator in banning alcohol. Rutherford was the first president to have a typewriter and telephone installed in the White House. The first phone call was to Alexander Graham Bell. Rutherford also hosted the first White House Easter Egg Roll on April 2, 1879, after Congress declared that the western slope of Capitol Hill and the Capital lawns could no longer be used.


Rutherford refused to run for second term, allowing James Garfield to succeed him. Following his retirement, Rutherford advocated for educational charities and was appointed to the Board of Trustees for Ohio State University. He also advocated for federal aid for education. Lucy Hayes died in 1889, which greatly grieved Rutherford. Rutherford died of a heart attack on January 17, 1893, in his home in Spiegel Grove, Ohio. He was 70 years of age.


Happy Birthday Mr. President!


For more information regarding financial support, please click here.